Re: Very interesting find
Posted: Thu May 27, 2010 6:40 am
Assumptions, in every case, determine conclusions.
Accept a fraudulent time line, and everything looks like it was copied from something older.
If, on the other hand, there was more or less one common tradition that coalesced into increasingly parochial (and arbitrary) recombinations as time passed (much as, on a smaller scale and shorter time span, Christian denominations have multiplied), you'd have the same state of affairs and without anybody copying from anybody. It would come about through selective exclusion rather than "borrowings."
In consequence you'd find (as you do when you look) quite a number of "odd coincidences" like (Hebrew) Pharisee (one set apart) and Parish (an area with a boundary) -- both illustrating a common term and concept [P(h)RS(h)] that supposedly have next to no connexion, from the traditions they appear in being only distantly and tangentally related.
Similarly, the Virgin Many and Baby Jesus would not have been cribbed from Isis and Horus, but both would have been contemporary. It would only seem that the Doors "copied" from Pink Floyd if PF were reassigned to a time long before them.
The Russians laid this out in detail, years ago.
Accept a fraudulent time line, and everything looks like it was copied from something older.
If, on the other hand, there was more or less one common tradition that coalesced into increasingly parochial (and arbitrary) recombinations as time passed (much as, on a smaller scale and shorter time span, Christian denominations have multiplied), you'd have the same state of affairs and without anybody copying from anybody. It would come about through selective exclusion rather than "borrowings."
In consequence you'd find (as you do when you look) quite a number of "odd coincidences" like (Hebrew) Pharisee (one set apart) and Parish (an area with a boundary) -- both illustrating a common term and concept [P(h)RS(h)] that supposedly have next to no connexion, from the traditions they appear in being only distantly and tangentally related.
Similarly, the Virgin Many and Baby Jesus would not have been cribbed from Isis and Horus, but both would have been contemporary. It would only seem that the Doors "copied" from Pink Floyd if PF were reassigned to a time long before them.
The Russians laid this out in detail, years ago.