Page 25 of 36

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 2:04 am
by Ishtar
john wrote:
The word I'd use is teleological.

Best example I can think of is, you are out there hunting with bow and arrow. A deer breaks loose from cover and you aim, not at the point the deer is NOW (you will surely miss) but at the point the deer will be in the future. In short, you are aiming your arrow and releasing it into empty space which you predict will be occupied by the dee

john
:lol:
Yes, except John, the deer/arrow example doesn't work in this case because non-ordinary reality (NOR) - which is what we've been trained to call this extra dimensionary place - is beyond time and space! So you'd need to fire your arrow at where the deer is now, not in a nanosecond's time.

I came up with the word 'television' partly to make a point - that it can be like a shared experience of watching a tv programme that's being beamed simultaneously all over the world. But I chose it also partly because journeying can be compared to the seeing referred to in the word 'seer', which is what some of the ancient prophets were called because they could see into the future.

In the case of the shamanic journey, you are seeing, but not into the future. You're seeing (and hearing, and smelling, and touching, and tasting) into an extra dimension of the here and now.

So based on that new information, see if you can come up with a more appropriate word! :lol:

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 2:31 am
by Ishtar
kbs2244 wrote:In spite of myself, I am getting drawn into this.
Well, don't worry about it KB! Just relax and enjoy the ride! :lol:

The only trouble with your post is that you're talking about Jethro and Moses as if they were real historical people, who actually existed. Based on that premise, your post makes a lot of sense.

But I think (and please correct me if I'm wrong all) we're well on the road now to establishing that the story of Moses, at least, is allegorical - if not an astrotheitical allegory - and so given this case, every character in the story (including Joshua, Jethro, Miriam and Aaron) are fictional characters, made up solely to tell a certain story.

If you have doubts, let's go over some of the facts:

In addition to the fact that the Moses-in-the-bulrushes story is a copy of Sargon of Akkad's, and significant aspects of the story of the crossing of the Red Sea have been taken from a similar story about the god El in Canaanite mythology,

http://www.worldagesarchive.com/Referen ... rpers).htm
A growing volume of evidence concerning Egyptian border defenses, desert sites where the fleeing Israelites supposedly camped, etc., indicates that the flight from Egypt ....never occurred at all...

...Beginning in the 1950s, doubts concerning the Book of Exodus multiplied just as they had about Genesis. The most obvious concerned the complete silence in contemporary Egyptian records concerning the mass escape of what the Bible says were no fewer than 603,550 Hebrew slaves. Such numbers no doubt were exaggerated. Yet considering how closely Egypt's eastern borders were patrolled at that time, how could the chroniclers of the day have failed to mention what was still likely a major security breach?

Not only was there a dearth of physical evidence concerning the escape itself, as archaeologists pointed out, but the slate was blank concerning the nearly five centuries that the Israelites had supposedly lived in Egypt prior to the Exodus as well as the forty years that they supposedly spent wandering in the Sinai.

Not so much as a skeleton, campsite, or cooking pot had turned up ...even though "modern archeological techniques are quite capable of tracing even the very meager remains of hunter-gatherers and pastoral nomads all over the world." Indeed, although archaeologists have found remains in the Sinai from the third millennium B.C. and the late first, they have found none from the thirteenth century.
Even the reason that the Jews were in Egypt (the brothers of Joseph followed him there, escaping famine in Canaan) now seems doubtful.

If you look at the story of Joseph, the main milestones of it are remarkably similar to someone else beginning with J - Jesus ben Joseph:

Joseph was born of a miracle birth, Jesus was born of a miracle birth. Joseph was of 12 brothers, Jesus had 12 disciples. Joseph was sold for 20 pieces of silver, Jesus was sold for 30 pieces of silver. Brother "Judah" suggests the sale of Joseph, disciple "Judas" suggests the sale of Jesus. Joseph began his work at the age of 30, Jesus began his work at the age of 30. And so on and on.

In my opinion, the belief that the stories in the Bible are all about the history of Israel is what's held us up for so long in our understanding about what actually did happen in that part of the world in the late BCs/early ADs (see, even our dating convention are dictated by these stories! :lol: ).

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 2:41 am
by Ishtar
Forum Monk wrote: When the age shifted to pisces, why didn't the followers begin sacrificing fish?
The age of Pisces is signfied in the Bible with the story of Jesus, in which he banned all animal sacrifices but gave himself as the Lamb for the slaughter, (the death of Aries, the Ram). But there are fish all over the Gospels. The Fisher of Men recruited disciples from fishermen. The feeding of the five thousand consisted of bread and fishes..I could go on.
Who would do such a thing? :shock:
Yes, who? :lol: Are you going to take it back now?

Interesting, yes. But I have said it before, I am an archaeo-astrono-skeptic.
You're kidding! :lol:

FM, it would be interesting to see a presentation on precession, By the way, Acharya says precession is mentioned in Enoch, but in true Acharya-style, doesn't give the quote or say which Enoch. You're just supposed to accept it because she says so. That's how she is! :cry:

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 3:44 am
by Ishtar
Minimalist wrote:Shit. I'm starting to feel like Marduk with all the Sumerian b.s.
Don't apologise for that, Min! :lol:

I never thought I'd say this, but we could really do with Marduk on here right now.

He must be killing himself laughing, if he's been viewing these posts, watching us all struggling around in Sumerian mythology and up to our necks in the sodding Enuma Anu Enlil, or whatever-the-flip it's called, trying to figure out what he knew years ago.

If you are reading this, Marduk, please have this one on us. We hope it's making you laugh as much as I did when you came up with your theory about the Sumerians being from South America.

Put your feet up and enjoy the entertainment! Cheers! :lol:

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 9:40 am
by Minimalist
<shudder>

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 11:56 am
by kbs2244
Ishtar:
My point was that Job was not a Hebrew.
And that I don't think you can use the book of Job as a dateing base.
There may have been some time between the stories occurance and it's being written down.

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 2:15 pm
by Ishtar
FM

This supports your dating of the sidereal zodiac to 700 BC. But there's some more interesting information besides:

http://w1.1564.telia.com/~u156400111/as ... eline1.htm

Babylon


2350 BC

Akkadians record solar & lunar eclipses according to tablets of Sargon of Akkad. Sargon summarizes astrological records of his era into 70 tablets. His heirs add their findings to this data base and call it the Namman-Bel.

2000 BC

Sumeria is replaced by Babylonia. Babylonian astrologers introduce zodiac signs and devise more accurate astronomical calculations.

1250 BC

Rameses II fixes 4 cardinal points using Aries, Cancer, Libra and Capricorn.

1200 BC

Babylonian Boundary stones contain much astrological imagery

700 BC

Babylonian priests create ecliptic divided into 12 30-degree sections or zodiac divisions (Mul.APIN).

670 BC

King Assurbanipal of Assyria expands astrological library in Ninevah.


Greece


600 BC

Babylonian astrology spreads to Egypt Greece and other parts of Middle East.

535 BC

Pythagoras sets up esoteric colony near Crotona in southern Italy where scholars learn about numerology, astrology and the occult arts, which Pythagoras learned during his 20 years of travels in Babylon and Egypt.

475 BC

Empedocles of Agrigentum introduces the 4 elements, Fire, Earth, Air and Water, into astrology, as the 4-fold root of all things. He discovered the idea that nothing can be destroyed (or created) only transformed.

420 BC

Democritus popularizes astrology for all. Xeno founder of the Stoics, gives zodiac signs Greek names.

409 BC

Date of oldest Babylonian horoscope.

380 BC

Babylonians begin to use 19 year cycle.

370 BC

Eudoxus of Cnidus devises calendars using zodiac with 12 equal zodiac signs. Invents geometrical theory of proportion.

350 BC

Petosiris, chief administrator of the Temple of Khumunu (Hermes) near Hermopolis becomes known for mastering egyptian esoteric astrology.

330 BC

Alexander the Great (356-323 BC) helps to spread astrology from Babylon and Egypt throughout the Middle East.

Greek Philosophers exposed to new occult ideas from Egypt and Babylon. Astrology is personalized in Greece.

Alexander founds Library of Alexandria.

300 BC

Greek model of Astrology reaches India.

290 BC

Alexandria in Egypt becomes center of astrological research. Eratosthenes, Arristyllus and Timocharis are its leading astrologers.

280 BC

Berosus, a Chaldean astrologer and priest of Bel Marduk at Babylon moves to Greek island of Cos where he sets up a school of astrology for Greek astrologers. Berosus writes The Babylonica, an enormous work about the history of astrology and life in Babylonia. He writes The Eye of Bel, based on the 70 tablets in the library of Assurbanipal, and uses it as text to teach Greek astrologers.

275 BC

The famous poem Phainomena written by Aratus in 275 BC further popularizes astrology and becomes common reading material for generations of Greeks.

250 BC

Antipatrus and Achinapolus continue the work of Berosus at Cos and teach medical astrology. They are the first astrologers to experiment with the moment of conception rather than birth for the casting of a horoscope.

220 BC

First known picture of zodiac in Egypt is created north of Esna.


Rome

200 BC

Predictive astrology spreads to Rome.

150 BC

Esoteric form of astrology based on the teachings of Hermes or Thoth circulates in numerous works under such titles as: Astrologoumena, Hermaikai Diataxeis or Doctrines of Hermes, Apokotastasis, Liber Hermetis, Asklepios.

135 BC

Posidonius brings astrology to Roman intellectuals.

130 BC

Greek astronomer Hipparchus is credited for the discovering the precession of the equinoxes which was already known in Babylonia centuries earlier. (my bolding)

100 BC

Essenes develop Qabbalah and esoteric astrology.

60 BC

Nigidius Figulus starts first school of astrology in Rome and publishes books on astrological prediction. The Georgics of Virgil constitute astrological almanacs.

20 BC

Roman Emperor Augustus has coins stamped with his sign Capricorn.

7 BC

Three Wise Men or Magi from the East (astrologers from Chaldea or Persia) predict birth of Messiah (Jesus Christ) according to Gospels of New Testament.



17

Egyptian zodiac at Denderah is erected.

50

Astrology has prominent role in Roman literature such as in The Tragedies of Seneca and Thyestes. Fourth Roman Emperor Claudius becomes versed in astrology. In his reign, Rome is caught up in a frenzy of astrology.

117

Roman Emperor Hadrian, also an astrologer, casts his own horoscope and consults it regularly.

150

Ptolemy writes The Tetrabiblos, the most comprehensive work on astrology to date. Already aware of the precession of the equinoxes, Ptolemy cautions astrologers to use the tropical spring equinox as the start of the first zodiac sign. Other astrologers such as Hephaestion of Thebes and Julius Firmicus use it as seminal work.

188

Vettius Valens of Antioch, well-known astrologer amasses fine library of horoscopes and analyzes 100 in his Anthologiae.

222

Alexander Serverus sets up teaching posts in astrology which are subsidized by the imperial budget.

250

Plotinus declares that astrology indicates a possible future but does not shape it.

400

Library of Alexandria is destroyed with loss of many astrology texts.

450

Proclus writes paraphrase of Ptolemy's Tetrabiblos.

476

Astrology declines in Europe with the Fall of the Roman Empire.
Wiki is quite interesting on the Babylonian star book, the MUL.APIN:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MUL.APIN

The earliest copy of the text so far discovered was made in 686 BCE, however the majority of scholars now believe that the text was originally compiled anywhere between 1400 and 1000 BCE. [1] The latest copies of Mul-Apin are currently dated to around 300 BCE.
I think the Babylonian MUL.APIN should tell us whether or not they had precession.

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 2:19 pm
by Ishtar
kbs2244 wrote:Ishtar:
My point was that Job was not a Hebrew.
And that I don't think you can use the book of Job as a dateing base.
There may have been some time between the stories occurance and it's being written down.
Thanks KB. We're not using him for dating.

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 4:54 pm
by kbs2244
OK, I will go back to the sidelines.
I went back and re-read you mention of The Book of Job.
You weren’t talking about the time of it’s occurrence, but about the time of it’s being written down?

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 5:05 pm
by Ishtar
kbs2244 wrote:OK, I will go back to the sidelines.
I went back and re-read you mention of The Book of Job.
You weren’t talking about the time of it’s occurrence, but about the time of it’s being written down?
There's no need to go back to the sidelines. Your contribution is appreciated.

I think I was discussing different ways of dating it according to whether the Bible is an historical document or not. In other words, an impossible task and not one we're likely to solve here.

Just like whether the Babylonians had precession or not. These are all big questions out there that greater minds than ours are wrestling with, when they're not wrestling with each other, that is!...so again, we're unlikely to solve it here.

Posted: Thu Jan 24, 2008 8:29 pm
by john
Ishtar wrote:
john wrote:
The word I'd use is teleological.

Best example I can think of is, you are out there hunting with bow and arrow. A deer breaks loose from cover and you aim, not at the point the deer is NOW (you will surely miss) but at the point the deer will be in the future. In short, you are aiming your arrow and releasing it into empty space which you predict will be occupied by the dee

john
:lol:
Yes, except John, the deer/arrow example doesn't work in this case because non-ordinary reality (NOR) - which is what we've been trained to call this extra dimensionary place - is beyond time and space! So you'd need to fire your arrow at where the deer is now, not in a nanosecond's time.

I came up with the word 'television' partly to make a point - that it can be like a shared experience of watching a tv programme that's being beamed simultaneously all over the world. But I chose it also partly because journeying can be compared to the seeing referred to in the word 'seer', which is what some of the ancient prophets were called because they could see into the future.

In the case of the shamanic journey, you are seeing, but not into the future. You're seeing (and hearing, and smelling, and touching, and tasting) into an extra dimension of the here and now.

So based on that new information, see if you can come up with a more appropriate word! :lol:

Ishtar -

To my way of thinking, the act of aiming and releasing an arrow into a presently empty space which I expect to be occupied when the arrow arrives has an incredible similarity to the shamanic journey.

Totally agreed, my example is of the physical world, and used metaphorically only.

However, consider the act of aiming and releasing your daimon into a place unoccupied by any physical phenomena (NOR), which you expect to be occupied when the daimon-arrow arrives. Which, being non-temporal, is effectively instantaneous in temporal terms, but actually simply time-less in terms of NOR. Aiming and releasing your daimon, unlike drawing a bow is not a physical event, but an act of both will and non-physical perception. An act of will has never been, and never will be a physical phenomenon. It is a teleological event which completely disregards the event horizon of the physical and temporal plane. Yet it passes unnoticed, daily, in its uniqueness.

FORTY

"Returning is the motion of the Tao.

Yielding is the way of the Tao.

Ten thousand things are born of being.

Being is born of not being."


-from the Tao Te Ching


john

Posted: Fri Jan 25, 2008 2:43 am
by Ishtar
john wrote:
Returning is the motion of the Tao.
Yielding is the way of the Tao.
Ten thousand things are born of being.
Being is born of not being.

-from the Tao Te Ching

john
What’s known as the classic shamanic journey is really a misnomer. You don’t actually go anywhere. You just drop down into a deeper and wider experience of NOW. It’s accessing the other 90 per cent of our brain that we don’t usually use, and thus a much wider reality than the one we’re usually in – this 10 per cent one being really just the lowest common denominator of a general consensus of what we’ve all agreed is reality.

This is turn gives you access to further and wider information about the present and puts you in touch with causation. So you can see what’s behind or get information about what’s causing a problem in this reality and get your metaphysical spanner out and fix it!

It puts you in touch with the energies (spirits/devas/gods) who run everything and who, luckily for us, turn out to be purely benevolent beings. Well, you’d have to be really. It’s purely an altruistic act, keeping this show on the road, and there’s nothing in it for them except, most of the time, misunderstanding and derision from us!

But whether or not there’s an all pervading, over-Arching (sorry Min!) Godhead who organises the whole lot, nobody knows - not even them. Even the most experienced shaman will tell you that their spirits don’t know of and have never met any monotheistic type God who decides who’s good and who’s bad, who keeps the planets revolving on their courses and makes and destroys universes at will.

On the other hand, I sometimes think there must be something that’s keeping this whole lot up! The spirits/gods say that it’s them. Fine. But who created the spirits?

Posted: Fri Jan 25, 2008 5:26 am
by Ishtar
I think War Arrow may have already mentioned this ...

... but there's a very good case for believing that the Maya had precession, based on their Long Count calendar. The part of the Mayan Great Cycle we're in is due to end on 21 December 2012 (winter solstice) and counting back to their Day Zero (0.0.0.0) on the Julian calendar, we get 3114 BC (close to when the Vedic calendar starts too).

http://www.levity.com/eschaton/Why2012.html


The point of interest for these early astronomers seems to have been the projected end date in 2012 A.D., rather than the beginning date in 3114 B.C.

Having determined the end date in 2012 (for reasons we will come to shortly), and calling it 13.0.0.0.0, they thus proclaimed themselves to be living in the 6th baktun of the Great Cycle.

The later Maya certainly attributed much mythological significance to the beginning date, relating it to the birth of their deities, but it now seems certain that the placement of the Long Count hinges upon its calculated end point.

Why did early Mesoamerican skywatchers pick a date some 2300 years into the future and, in fact, how did they pinpoint an accurate winter solstice? With all these considerations one begins to suspect that, for some reason, the ancient New World astronomers were tracking precession.
So how did they do it?
I have concluded that even cultures with simple horizon astronomy and oral records passed down for a hundred years or so, would notice the slow shifting of the heavens.

For example, imagine that you lived in an environment suited for accurately demarcated horizon astronomy. Even if this wasn't the case, you might erect monoliths to sight the horizon position of, most likely, the dawning winter solstice sun.

This position in relation to background stars could be accurately preserved in oral verse or wisdom teachings, to be passed down for centuries. Since precession will change this position at the rate of 1 degree every 72 years, within the relatively short time of 100 years or so, a noticeable change will have occurred. The point of this is simple. To early cultures attuned to the subtle movements of the sky, precession would not have been hard to notice.
If this theory is correct, imho then there's every reason to believe that that's how other civs, including the Sumerians, did it - especially given ...

... Boats, Hematite and Teleology.

To track precession, you'd need to notice a one degree shift every 72 years. For civs that kept astrological records (Sumerians/Vedics) surely this wouldn't be so difficult. We know that the Sumerians and Vedics divided time into units of 60, so why did they do that? What did they know? Maybe they knew about precession.

Posted: Fri Jan 25, 2008 8:41 am
by War Arrow
Er... I didn't and to be honest I'm a bit sketchy on the Mayan calendar though for what it's worth, most of my sources (and notably Gordon Brotherston whom I tend to trust) have that date as 3113* BCE rather than 3114. Also I gather that 2012 equation may be a little suspect being as it depends upon how you choose to compensate for leap year systems (the version I heard suggests that 2012 doesn't, although there was a leap year equivalent in use - the Mexica had it so I've no doubt the Maya did)... sorry I can't be of more help, though I don't think any of this necessarily affects your initial point.

I wasn't kidding when I said I'm ludicrously specialised. I've probably got Motecuhzoma's inside leg measurement writen down somewhere but as soon as you get further east than Tlaxcala I'm back in head scratching territory.

* = in fact I have come across this date calculated to 13th August 3113 BCE somewhere or other, though it somehow seems a bit too similar to the crucial 13th August 1521 for comfort.

Posted: Fri Jan 25, 2008 11:31 am
by kbs2244
I think the Maya thing was one of my lobs from the sidelines Ish.
I have always been intrigued by the India / Maya connection.
Half a world apart, and with some pretty complex sailing and navigation between them, but connections keep popping up.
Their calendar starting date is but one.
The other that always comes up is the Maze held by statues in Hindu temples