Thank you, Cogs. I had no idea the whole matter was so tricky. So it was very helpful to have it explained in such a clear way.
But here's my thinking:
Am I right that we're saying that the Atlantic Ocean was the Sea of Atlas, and was possibly named after the Atlas mountains?
If so, in the mythology, Atlas is the son of Poseiden, the sea god - and Plato tells us that there was a huge, elaborately ornate temple at the centre of Atlantis that was dedicated to Poseiden.
Added to that, Madame Blavatsky (who got her information from two Indian mahatmas in the 19th century), in The Secret Doctrine says:
The huge continent we call Atlantis, the continent of the fourth Race, named Kusha in the occult records, embraced northern Asia - untouched, as said, from Lemurian times - stretching far to the north of the great sea, now the Gobi Desert; it extended eastwards, in a solid block of land, including China and Japan, and passed beyond them across the present northern Pacific Ocean, till it almost touched the western coast of North America; southwards it covered India and Ceylon, Burmah, and the Malay peninsula, and westwards included Persia, Arabia and Syria, the Red Sea and Abyssinia, occupying the basin of the Mediterranean, covering southern Italy and Spain, and, projecting from Scotland and Ireland, then above the waters, into what is now sea, it stretched westwards, covering the present Atlantic Ocean and a large part of North and South America.
The catastrophe which rent it, in the mid-Miocene, about four million years ago, into seven islands, of varying size, brought to the surface Norway and Sweden, much of southern Europe, Egypt, nearly all Africa, and much of North America, while sinking northern Asia, and breaking Atlantis off from the Imperishable Sacred Land. The lands later called Ruta and Daitya, the present bed of the Atlantic, were rent away from America, but a great belt of land still connected them, a belt submerged in the catastrophe of 850,000 years ago, in theatre Pliocene, leaving the two lands as separate islands. These, again, perished, some 200,000 years ago, leaving Poseidonis in the midst of the Atlantic.
So, if this is true (and I have no idea if it is), Plato could be referring to the island of Poseidonis as Atlantis, when in fact, it was all the remained of the much larger Atlantis from a catastrophe of 850,000 years ago.
Does anyone know if this fits any known geological models?
She goes on:
After the disappearance of Poseidonis, (the last remaining island after the Deluge) the deterioration of the scattered Atlantean tribes was rapid, though the Atlanteans in the east of Asia held their own and the Polynesians, Samoans and Tongas are surviving relics. Some of the tribes even sank so low as to intermarry with the hybrid creatures that sprang from the sin of the mindless. Others intermarried with the degraded remnants of the seventh Lemurian sub-race, and the Veddahs of Ceylon are the descendants from such unions, as are the hairy men of Borneo, the Andaman Islanders, Bushmen, and some Australian aborigines. The majority of the inhabitants of the earth are still Fourth Round people, but the only ones that seem to have future are the Japanese, and perhaps the Chinese.
Now, I don't know if there ever was an Atlantis. The jury in my head is definitely out on it, although I've read a lot about it. I also have no idea if Madame Blavatsky's mahatmas were correct.
But my point of posting all this is to show the link in the mythology between Poseiden, father of Atlas, and the Sea of Atlas, or Atlantis Sea.
So this dovetails neatly into your quote from the wonderful Online Etymological Dictionary (my bolding):
Atlantic ocean
1387, ocean of athlant "sea off the west coast of Africa," from L. Atlanticus, from Gk. Atlantikos, adjectival form of Atlas (gen. Atlantos), in ref. to Mount Atlas in Mauritania (see Atlas). Applied to the whole ocean since 1601.
So maybe I should write that book!
